At Consumer Connection, we specialize in recruiting for Natural Products — the kinds you’ll see walking the floors at Expo West in Anaheim. Whether you’re a pre-revenue startup preparing for launch or a $200M company navigating hypergrowth, we’re the startup hiring partner that understands the unique demands of the space.
Within a specific niche like natural foods, where passion and authenticity really matter, the best natural products recruiters stand out by going way beyond just filling roles. Here's what separates the top-tier from the "meh":
________________________________________
🌿 1. Deep Industry Roots (Not Just Surface-Level Knowledge)
Top recruiters:
• Know the difference between organic certification and clean label marketing.
• Understand retail dynamics (like what it takes to get into Sprouts vs. Erewhon).
• Can speak the language of functional ingredients, adaptogens, and sustainable supply chains.
Average ones:
• Might lump natural foods in with general CPG.
• Don’t really “get” why a founder would be picky about regenerative sourcing or B Corp values.
________________________________________
🤝 2. Real Relationships (Not Just a Rolodex)
Top recruiters:
• Have deep, trusted relationships with both brands and talent.
• Know who’s quietly open to new roles or who’s launching something soon.
• Can “vibe check” candidates culturally—whether they’ll click with a scrappy startup vs. a mission-driven heritage brand.
Average ones:
• Rely mostly on job boards and LinkedIn blasts.
• Don’t really know the nuances behind someone’s resume or company fit.
________________________________________
🔍 3. Cultural Matchmaking (Not Just Skill Matching)
Top recruiters:
• Think like brand storytellers and culture curators.
• They find people who live and breathe the same values—like sustainability, wellness, transparency.
• They get that a great hire isn’t just qualified—they’re aligned.
Average ones:
• Focus mainly on years of experience or titles.
• Don’t ask deeper questions about mission, lifestyle, or personal alignment.
________________________________________
🧠 4. Strategic Talent Advising (Not Just Filling Jobs)
Top recruiters:
• Help early-stage brands figure out what kind of hire they actually need.
• Know when to advise a fractional hire vs. full-time, or when to bring in someone with exit experience.
• Stay current on industry shifts—like AI in food transparency or regenerative ag trends.
Average ones:
• Just fill job descriptions without challenging them.
• Don’t think long-term about team scaling.
________________________________________
✨ Bonus: They Believe in the Industry
The best natural products recruiters often live the lifestyle:
• They eat the food, use the products, and care about the same things their clients and candidates do.
• That authenticity builds real trust in a space that values mission over margin.
Beyond the “best of the best,” natural products recruiters can cover a range of businesses focused on things like:
• Organic food & beverages
• Nutritional supplements
• Clean beauty & personal care
• Natural/eco-friendly household products
• Herbal or plant-based remedies
Here's what they typically do:
🧠 Understand the Industry:
They know the natural products world inside and out—like ingredient trends, sustainability practices, regulatory standards (e.g., USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project), and what kind of talent thrives in mission-driven, eco-conscious companies.
🔍 Source Candidates:
They find people for roles like:
• VP Sales, Heads of Sales, Channel Specific Sales Directors and Managers with past industry success that can be replicated
• Product developers or R&D scientists
• Supply chain/logistics folks with sustainability chops
• Regulatory & quality assurance specialists
• Executives who understand the mission-driven market
💬 Match Culture & Mission:
A huge part of this space is values—so they focus on people who not only have the right skills but are genuinely aligned with things like sustainability, health, wellness, and ethical sourcing.
🤝 Work with Startups & Legacy Brands:
They might help tiny startups breaking into Whole Foods or big players launching new wellness-focused lines.
